BUYING VS RENTING COMPARISON
Imagine two households looking for a three-bedroom home in March 2022. One buys for $840,000. The other rents for $2,500 a month. By March 2027, the five-year cost of renting could be about $153,000 lower.
The renter stays put and pays about $158,300 over five years, assuming the landlord applies B.C.’s standard annual rent increases. The buyer puts $168,000 down, pays about $188,750 in mortgage payments and spends an assumed $30,000 more than the renter on property taxes, municipal fees, insurance and upkeep.
The buyer pays down almost $99,000 of the mortgage. But suppose the home loses 22.8% of its value, matching the drop in Canada’s benchmark from its March 2022 peak to October 2026. The house would then be worth about $648,500. If the buyer sold at that price and paid off the remaining mortgage, they would walk away with about $75,200 before selling costs. That’s roughly $93,000 less than the original down payment. Better Dwelling’s report on the national benchmark.
Subtract what the buyer would get back from what they put in, and the five-year cost of owning comes to about $311,500, compared with $158,300 in rent. If the buyer stays and renews at an illustrative 4.5%, the monthly mortgage payment rises from $3,146 to $3,614, before taxes, fees, insurance and upkeep.
The outcome depends on what that particular home would sell for in 2027. In this example, the renter paid less each month and kept the money the buyer needed for a down payment. The buyer did what homeowners are told to do and paid down the mortgage every month. The price drop still left them with less equity than they started with.

Comments
Post a Comment
Pending moderation, your comment will be published. Thank You