Canada is not creating a sovereign wealth fund from surplus wealth. It is borrowing to create the appearance of surplus wealth.
Borrowed Wealth
A sovereign wealth fund is supposed to be what a country builds when it has wealth to spare.
Canada is now trying something different: a sovereign wealth fund built with borrowed money.
Prime Minister Mark Carney’s Canada Strong Fund is being launched with an initial C$25 billion to invest in major domestic projects alongside the private sector. Reuters reported the fund at C$25 billion, or about US$18.38 billion, and said it will grow through asset recycling and reinvestment. (Reuters)
The phrase “sovereign wealth fund” carries a certain glow. It evokes Norway. Oil money. Surpluses. Patient capital. A nation saving today’s bounty for tomorrow’s citizens.
But Canada is not launching this fund from surplus. Canada is launching it while running deficits.
The Parliamentary Budget Officer says Budget 2025 projects federal deficits averaging C$64.3 billion annually from 2025–26 to 2029–30. (Parliamentary Budget Officer) That is the context. Ottawa is not taking excess cash off the top and putting it aside. It is adding a C$25 billion investment vehicle to an already strained public balance sheet.
So let’s call this what it is: borrowed wealth.
The government will argue that this is investment, not spending. Fair enough. If Ottawa borrows at one rate and the fund earns a higher return, taxpayers could benefit. That is the theory. Borrow at 3.5%, earn 6%, build assets, compound returns, strengthen the economy. On a spreadsheet, it can work.
But spreadsheets do not pay interest. Taxpayers do.
Reuters reported Canada’s 10-year yield at 3.499% on April 27. (Reuters) At roughly that rate, C$25 billion costs about C$875 million a year to carry once fully funded. Even at 3%, the interest bill is C$750 million a year.
That is not a rounding error. That is a permanent-looking line item unless someone explains how it ends.
And that is the question Ottawa has not answered clearly enough: does the fund repay the seed money, or do taxpayers simply service the debt while the fund keeps the gains?
Because there is a big difference between a public investment that returns money to the treasury and a public investment that reinvests its profits inside itself. If the Canada Strong Fund earns money but folds those returns back into the fund, then the vehicle grows while the federal government still carries the borrowing cost. The fund compounds. The taxpayer pays.
That may be defensible. It may even be smart. But it should not be sold as costless.
Federal money is not just fungible. In Ottawa, it can become fudgable: moved across columns until borrowing looks like investment, debt service disappears into the wallpaper, and Canadians are told the asset belongs to them even while they keep paying the interest on it.
The government should answer three plain questions before the first dollar moves.
Will the Canada Strong Fund repay the original C$25 billion to the federal treasury?
Will it pay dividends or distributions to offset federal debt-service costs?
Or will the returns be kept inside the fund while taxpayers finance the borrowing indefinitely?
Those questions matter because governments do not retire debt by giving it a better name. Bonds mature, but public debt is often rolled over. New borrowing replaces old borrowing. The label changes; the obligation remains.
This is why the phrase “sovereign wealth fund” deserves scrutiny. A country with surplus wealth can create a sovereign fund without asking future taxpayers to finance the seed capital. A deficit-running country can still create an investment fund, but it should be honest about the bargain.
Canada is borrowing money in the hope that government-directed investment can earn more than the cost of capital.
Maybe it can. But then show the hurdle rate. Show the governance. Show the repayment policy. Show how taxpayers benefit directly, not just how the fund grows larger.
A Canada Strong Fund that builds profitable assets and sends real returns back to the public could be a serious tool. A Canada Strong Fund that borrows C$25 billion, reinvests its own gains, and leaves taxpayers with the carrying cost is something else.
That is not sovereign wealth.
That is a sovereign tab.
Comments
Post a Comment
Pending moderation, your comment will be published. Thank You