If the Abuse Is Big Enough, Nobody Pays
Canada’s Federal Court of Appeal has now confirmed what many Canadians already suspected: Ottawa’s use of the Emergencies Act crossed the line. The court said the invocation was unreasonable, ultra vires—beyond legal authority—and that key measures infringed Charter protections for freedom of expression and against unreasonable search and seizure.
That is not a small technical error.
That is the state using extraordinary power it was not lawfully entitled to use.
And yet, what is the real consequence?
For ordinary citizens, breaking rules brings fines, court dates, frozen accounts, seized property, or jail. For government, even when a court says it acted outside the law, the penalty is usually political spin, legal language, and a fast effort to move on.
That is the double standard people are sick of.
The Emergencies Act was supposed to be tightly constrained. The Court of Appeal said Parliament drafted it narrowly to avoid the abuses associated with the old War Measures Act, and still the government failed to show reasonable grounds that the legal threshold had been met or that existing laws were insufficient.
So let’s say it plainly.
If a citizen overreaches, the law arrives with teeth.
If the state overreaches, the law arrives with a press release.
That is not equal justice. That is a protected class.
You do not need to support the convoy to be alarmed by this. In fact, the less you liked the protest, the more carefully you should want governments restrained by law. Rights are not tested by the people you agree with. They are tested by the people you don’t.
And this ruling tells us something bigger than one protest, one prime minister, or one bad decision.
It tells us the system is very good at punishing the little guy and very weak at punishing power.
That is the real scandal.
Not just that emergency power was used unlawfully.
But that in Canada, the higher the office, the thinner the accountability.
A free country cannot stay free if governments can break legal limits and walk away with little more than embarrassment.
Canadians are left staring at an ugly conclusion:
If the abuse is big enough, nobody pays.
Comments
Post a Comment
Pending moderation, your comment will be published. Thank You